13 Responses

  1. Wow!! So this overtakes the pumpkin power rankings?? And is it chunky? With actual cookie pieces? Just out of comparison how would you rate their normal cookie butter? I bet these would be really good on muffins or maybe even warmed a bit and drizzled on vanilla ice cream (or pumpkin ice cream :))

  2. Junk Male says:

    It’s filled with real cookie bits, like crunchy cookie butter. Actual cookie butter is probably an 8.5 easy. This is a 10. I will defend that rating until the end of time.

  3. Wow!! Have to try this stuff!!

  4. Maybe I’ll try making pumpkin pie spice cookie butter cookies!!

  5. Hayley says:

    Going to TJs on Monday and this is on my list!!! Great review! ??

  6. Hayley says:

    Oh no!!!! RIP Pumpkin Cookie Butter. 🙁 I actually went to Trader Joes today, bought a jar of the pumpkin cookie butter, a box of the ginger-pumpkin ice cream bites, Pumpkin pop tarts and the bread pudding. My cart looked ridiculous. Lol Can’t wait for that pumpkin cheat day. I might turn into an actual pumpkin and have to be rolled outta the house. ?

    • Junk Male says:

      Pumpkin cheat day sounds like a blast! Despite having the worst name on the planet, I’ve heard the ginger-pumpkin ice cream mouthfuls are insanely good! I haven’t tried their pop tarts or bread pudding, so you’ll have to keep us posted! I did pick up the Pumpkin O’s cereal, harvest salsa, pumpkin seed brittle, and pumpkin cranberry crisps. I guess we’ll both be pumpkins within a week.

  7. TheIcon says:

    Why does yours look so runny? It looks like the consistency of natural PB. Mine has always been thick almost like bean paste.

  8. Caitlin says:

    Just called at my local trader joes to see if this was in stock yet aaaaand he said they are doing it this year!!!!!!!!!!! I’m dead.

    • Caitlin says:

      i meant NOT doing it this year- see? I’m a wreck!

      • Junk Male says:

        I KNOW. I just found this out this weekend as well. I’m so sad. I have one saved from last year for emergencies like this. My guess is they had a problem with the supplier? I don’t know, I can’t imagine that this didn’t sell well the last two years to justify this.

        • Oshyan says:

          Same experience. Went to TJ’s today to get it, rather excited. Had to settle for pumpkin cheesecake instead. Which, of course, is no substitute. Considering starting a petition to bring it back. Supply issues? I can’t imagine, unless the pumpkin spice fervor has put the spices (or even pumpkins) into short supply around this time…