6 Responses

  1. Sarah says:

    These sound like a solid cookie…not going to blow minds but not going to disgust anyone either. Wonder how these would do frozen! I have actually never frozen an Oreo (can’t really remember the last time I had an Oreo tbh…). But since you compared them to thin mints and I know loads of people who freeze thin mints wonder how successful that would be. I was asking someone the other day what their favorite cookie is. I think they said chocolate chip. And I heard Americas favorite cookie is an Oreo. What is your favorite type of cookie? (Including store bought and homemade varieties). Great review!

    • Junk Male says:

      Hmm… I’m just not sure how an Oreo would hold up in the freezer, but I will literally try anything. I know people like frozen Pop Tarts… I tried it and didn’t understand it. My favorite Girl Scout cookie is the Samoa. My absolute favorite cookie are those rainbow 7-layer cookies with the red, green, and yellow cakes covered with jelly betwern the layers and covered in chocolate. My second favorite cookie is anything anyone puts in front of me.

  2. The first sarah says:

    Omg – these are NOTHING like the mint creme or candy cane Oreos!!
    Candy cane has crunchy bits and is therefore superior but not as munchable. Mint creme is green and therefore dead to me. These are good.

    I’ve never eaten any of them, of course.

    And I hate pink and favor green in all things except mint. None of this makes any sense. Keep it up!

    • Junk Male says:

      These are all excellent points, Sarah. Please write for our blog. I will let you two Sarah’s fight over who is the better Sarah, while I eat Angie’s Boom Chicka Pop Hot Cocoa Marshmallow popcorn.

    • Kaitlyn says:

      lmao.. i think i love you, first sarah

  3. Kaitlyn says:

    damnit, stacey.