6 Responses

  1. Gretchen says:

    McDonald’s apple pies never did much for me, but tbh, apple pie is probably the last on my list of favorite pies. Coming from a smores poptart lover, I’d much rather have the smores one. Also, you can now rate your “How many of you are going to weight in on the comments below rating” as a 2 out of 10 😉

    • Junk Male says:

      Thank you for being brave enough to start the comment thread Gretchen! Very un-American of you to not like Apple Pie, but I respect your taste preferences. Having now tried all three, you will be pleased that the S’mores is my favorite. Once people can actually find these things, pick them up in place of the Pop Tarts!

  2. Kiran Hapke says:

    I love the apple pies from mcd’s so I’d probably love these just because that means I won’t eat a pie plus a Sprite and a bag of fries at the same time if I make it at home. Of course I’d probably end up eating all 4 mini pies at once so maybe I should just go to McDonald’s and save myself the time, hmmm.

    • Junk Male says:

      Oh make no mistake, you’re in for a treat if you like the McDonald’s Apple Pies. I baked two and I let one of them cool. As it cools, especially if you refridgerate any of it, it’s straight Mickey D’s Apple Pie. Piping hot, there’ll be some differences and it’s a better quality but the flavor profile is the same. I hope you love them (you will).

  3. I read your review and “Unchained Melody” started playing on an endless loop in my mind.