8 Responses

  1. Anonymous says:

    At first, I thought they were all fruit flavored because of the colors of the packaging (I thought 1 was blueberry/lime, 2 was a citrus flavor, and 3 was grape/raspberry). I am thinking of buying them this weekend and trying all of these out to see what I think of them.

    • Junk Male says:

      My head went to the exact same place regarding packaging, but that theory was immediately squashed by chocolate. Report back what you think after you try them!

      • Anonymous says:

        I am most interested in trying 3 (the cherry cola one) because I am wondering what I would think of a soda flavored marshmallow. The one I am least interested in trying is 2 (I don’t like the popcorn jelly bellys, anything sweet and buttered popcorn flavored sounds gross, while I do like popcorn in its pure, original form). 1 seems like an interesting one, it might either be a new or an existing chocolate flavor. When I get these and try them out, my final verdicts will be posted.

        Who knows, maybe next year, there might be 4 mystery flavors. I am thinking of maybe taste testing these with some other people, and adding the original flavor (they have original flavored white peeps) as a mystery flavor #4, so people will have 4 mystery flavors to guess from instead of just 3.

  2. Marc P says:

    Fun review. Another freaking smores product I have to try. What a tough life.

    In the words of Homer…. mmmmmmmm mystery donut

  3. Anonymous says:

    Tried #1 and #2.
    #1 – Tastes like those chocolate covered marshmallow eggs. Grade: B+
    #2 – Very light popcorn taste, but it smells like cheese/stinky feet. Grade: C

    I actually ate 10 peeps in one sitting. I will try #3 later.

  4. Junk Male says:

    Haha! I made sure not to eat all five in each package, because I was really hoping to wake up in the morning. I’m really curious on what exactly #1 is, though I am nearly certain #2 is butter. It HAS to be popcorn. Interesting call on the cheese angle, though… I could see some of that to an extent We’ll find out soon enough!

  5. Anonymous says:

    Tried #3. It tasted like a rainbow berry Airheads Xtremes to me