Cookie butter has been all the rage for a few years now, but is there such a thing as TOO MUCH cookie butter?

Find out tonight on this week’s episode of: They’re Trying To Kill Me. 😩

Blue Bunny Cookie Butter Ice Cream

Blue Bunny Cookie Butter Ice Cream

Okay, this is absurd. Blue Bunny Cookie Butter is speculoos cookie flavored ice cream, speculoos caramel swirl, speculoos cookie dough chunks, and a cinnamon graham swirl because why the hell not at that point?

This is a Cookie Butter Lover’s best dream and worst nightmare combined, plus a little more cookie butter than that.

Cookie Butter ice creams exist, but nobody has infused it into every single component like Blue Bunny has.

I think they may have even consulted Xzibit on this one.

I’ve never been so ready to die in my entire life…

Blue Bunny Cookie Butter Ice Cream

I don’t know that I’ve ever had an ice cream that is so unified with so much variety as Blue Bunny Cookie Butter ice cream. Everything tastes like cookie butter, but each element adds something slightly different to elevate the final product to something much more special.

Now, the quality of the ice cream isn’t premium and understandably so at the price point. Its texture is a little gummy but the flavors are absolutely on point. The base is a sweet cinnamon with notes of brown sugar and honey, and then the mix-ins are so prominent that every spoonful will deliver something even tastier.

Blue Bunny Cookie Butter Ice Cream

The cinnamon graham swirl is the most prevalent mix-in and I wouldn’t have it any other way. It has a heavy graham flavor amplified with cinnamon sugar and offers a gritty crunch that’s so much fun to chew on.

I’ve never had speculoos cookie dough before, so major props to Blue Bunny for tossing this in. The base and graham swirl already offer so much cinnamon and honey that it’s hard to pull out the cookie dough’s signature traits. In fact, ignoring how parentheses work, the word “cinnamon” appears five separate times in the ingredient list. The word honey three times. The cookie dough just tastes like brown sugar cookie dough, but it’s a really welcomed addition because cookie dough.

Bottom line: this ice cream is so authentic.

Blue Bunny Cookie Butter Ice Cream

The only thing Blue Bunny Cookie Butter could use more of is that speculoos caramel swirl, which will run thin or absent in large areas in the center of the container. But even that tastes like speculoos when you find it, further driving home that Blue Bunny cut no corners to deliver a lethal injection of cookie butter with this ice cream.

The answer to the opening question is this: there’s officially no such thing as too much cookie butter. This is one of the most addictive ice creams I’ve eaten in a long while.

Thanks Xzibit!

Cookie Butter Rating: 9 out of 10
Cookie Butter Rating: 9 out of 10
Overall Rating: 9 out of 10

To keep up with all of our product finds and Junk Bantering in real time, follow us on social media at the links below!

: junkbanter

To contact us via e-mail, send a message to

Facebook Comments